Juvenile Justice in Namibia: Law reform towards reconciliation and restorative justice?
نویسنده
چکیده
Stefan Schulz and Marthinus Hamutenya* Polytechnic of Namibia 2003 Abstract: Namibia is a newly independent nation, which in the wake of colonial oppression and foreign rule has yet to develop a comprehensive juvenile justice system. The current criminal justice system is informed by stereotyped common sense concepts of ‘criminality’ and ‘the criminal’. Simplistic views undergirded by utilitarian arguments have put Namibia at odds with international instruments, such as the United Nations Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice (Beijing Rules) and the Convention on the Rights of Children (CRC), which have embraced a holistic perspective on juvenile crime and deviance. In the spirit of ‘Ubuntu’, a frame of mind prevalent in sub-Saharan Africa, which relates to a specific communal approach to the notion of people, Namibia has set forth to establish a restorative juvenile justice system. This endeavor has led to the drafting of the Child Justice Bill, which is under scrutiny in this article. The authors highlight the arguments behind the most important parts of the draft Bill, and assess the merits of the proposed law against the backdrop of international legal instruments and law reform projects of other countries.
منابع مشابه
Criminal Mediation as a Doctrine of Restorative Justice from the Perspective of Law and Ethics
Background: Creating the ground for peace and reconciliation through recourse to arbitration has been one of the common methods of litigation that is rooted in ethics. In the criminal justice system, judicial and police officials are the reference for investigation, inquiry and investigation. The sovereign and their representatives have the exclusive competence and no other person has the autho...
متن کاملA Comparison of Four Restorative Conferencing Models
Restorative justice is a framework for juvenile justice reform that seeks to engage victims, offenders and their families, other citizens, and community groups both as clients of juvenile justice services and as resources in an effective response to youth crime. Traditionally, when a crime is committed, juvenile justice systems have been primarily concerned with three questions: Who did it? Wha...
متن کاملThe Personal and the Political: Forgiveness and Reconciliation in Restorative Justice
At the center of this paper are three questions: in the absence of a religious worldview, can one gain access to the concepts of forgiveness and reconciliation, can reconciliation be achieved in the absence of forgiveness or does the former depend in some way upon the latter, and can we make sense of a restorative approach to justice in the absence of either forgiveness or reconciliation? To an...
متن کاملReconciliation and Justice after Genocide: A Theoretical Exploration
This article argues that the post-conflict reconciliation process is undermined by the importance given to the retributive form of justice dominating peacebuilding and transitional justice measures. Retributive justice reinforces the division between perpetrator and victim, thus undermining the reconciliation process between antagonistic parties. The so-called objective categories of perpetrato...
متن کاملRestorative Approach of Justice; Pathology & Operation Improvement
Penalization & treatment have been proposed in criminal justice system. In the last decades of the twentieth century, penalization system has been seriously criticized, the approach that gives no significant role to all stakeholders of crime. Particularly victim, who is merely, means to prove the crime. Theory of treatment the offender / rehabilitation also, mainly criticized with the lack o...
متن کامل